Rights

Wangchuk Writes to Amit Shah, Questions Legality of Restrictions on Movement

On November 12, Wangchuk had alleged that he was placed under house arrest at his university residence in Leh.

Wangchuk Writes to Amit Shah, Questions Legality of Restrictions on Movement

Climate activist Sonam Wangchuk. (File photo)

Climate activist and education reformist Sonam Wangchuk has challenged the restrictions imposed on him by the Ladakh administration, writing to Union Home Minister Amit Shah and Lieutenant Governor Vinai Kumar Saxena that the order violates his fundamental rights.

The order bars him from “engaging in any activity, organising or participating in any unauthorised rally, procession or public gathering” for 60 days, The Tribune reported.

Wangchuk argued that the restrictions infringe upon his constitutional rights to freedom of movement and speech, and questioned the legal basis for effectively confining him to his residence.

On November 12, Wangchuk had alleged that he was placed under house arrest at his university residence in Leh. This came a day after police removed him from a protest site in the city and escorted him back to his residence.

“The imposition of the Model Code of Conduct, as recorded in the order, cannot, by itself, be invoked as a blanket justification to curtail this right or to impose restrictions that effectively confine me to my residence, in the absence of any intervening reason,” he wrote, adding that the right to peaceful protest is a fundamental right guaranteed to every citizen.

Questioning the wording of the district administration's order, Wangchuk pointed out that it does not explicitly mention either “house arrest” or “detention”.

“It nowhere directs me to remain at my residence – a direction given orally to me by the personnel who picked me up and are now present outside my house.” he said.

“The order does not mention the scope or extent of the restrictions imposed on my movement, leaving their implementation to the discretion of the police personnel deployed.”

Recounting the events of November 11, Wangchuk said he was “forcefully pushed” into a vehicle by a group of masked men without being told where he was being taken. Police personnel in plain clothes, accompanied by a uniformed officer, had entered a tent at the site where a demonstration was scheduled to take place.

“I was told to remain at home under the supervision of police guards. Since that evening, dozens of armed police personnel (approximately twenty to twenty-two) have been stationed at and around my residence and continue to remain deployed there as I write this representation,” Wangchuk said, going on to emphasise the arbitrary nature of the order.

He further questioned the necessity of imposing restrictions for such an extended period, arguing that the administration had failed to provide any specific grounds for the action.

“The order discloses no reasons justifying the necessity or proportionality of such an extended restriction, nor does it identify any continuing emergency/threat attributable to me that would warrant restraints of such duration,” he said.

Meanwhile, protests have intensified in Ladakh over the scheduling of the hill council elections for December 4, with residents and political groups objecting to the decision to hold the polls during the region's harsh winter months.

The elections, covering eight districts, coincide with the period of seasonal migration and severe weather conditions in Ladakh.

Protesters have warned that the timing could create considerable difficulties for voters, potentially affecting participation and resulting in a low turnout. The controversy has also raised concerns over the administration's handling of democratic rights and peaceful dissent in the region.

Comments (0)

Leave a Comment

   Can't Read ? Click    Refresh