He made the remarks during an interaction with students at the University of Chicago on Wednesday (November 18), stressing that talks could not take place while innocent Indians continued to be killed.
Gandhi was responding to a question from a participant who identified himself as a Pakistani national. The participant asked whether the two neighbouring countries could “move beyond the blame game and work together for mutual benefit” without allowing external factors to exploit their differences.
“There is room, but there is a big problem, which is the support and encouragement of terrorism by Pakistan in our country,” Gandhi said.
“And it is impossible for us to accept our innocent people being murdered and having a conversation with Pakistan. So, the moment that stops, then a conversation can potentially begin,” Gandhi added.
The Congress leader also launched a sharp criticism of the Narendra Modi government's foreign policy, arguing that India was increasingly losing its influence in international affairs despite its economic size, history and diplomatic relationships.
Referring to Pakistan's reported role in facilitating negotiations between the United States and Iran, Gandhi questioned why India was not playing a more active part in such diplomatic engagements.
"India, by its size, naturally has a global voice and India should be actively involved in global conversations. But frankly, India has become a side player," he said. "I'm pretty shocked that Pakistan is busy negotiating with the Iranians and the Americans, and India's just looking," he stated.
The BJP responded sharply to Gandhi's criticism. Party national spokesperson CR Kesavan accused the Congress leader of siding with Pakistan, saying, “Rahul Gandhi comes across as a cheerleader and a shameless propagandist for Pakistan,”
Gandhi argued that India needed to recover its independent foreign policy tradition, recalling its leading role in the Non-Aligned Movement (NAM), established in 1961. The grouping brought together countries seeking to maintain independence from the rival US- and Soviet-led blocs during the Cold War. Jawaharlal Nehru, India's first prime minister, was among its founding leaders.
In a post on X on Thursday, Gandhi reiterated his concerns over India's absence from international diplomatic discussions, saying he was “pretty shocked” that Pakistan was negotiating with Iran and the US while India was “just looking”.
“India has always had a sophisticated geopolitical understanding, right from independence. We had a mind of our own. Our foreign policy was guided by what benefits India,” he said.
“By our size, our history and our relationships, we should be involved in these global conversations. But frankly, India has become a side player. We have stepped back from the stage. We have a voice and a view, but that view is missing,” he further said.
He also referred to the wider consequences of the Iran war for India, arguing that developments beyond the country's borders had a direct impact on people's lives and economic conditions.
“There was already pain in India. The Iran war magnified it, pushing people over the edge. We cannot sit in India and remain unconcerned about what is happening in the rest of the world,” the Congress leader added.
I’m pretty shocked that Pakistan is busy negotiating with the Iranians and the Americans, while India is just looking. India has always had a sophisticated geopolitical understanding, right from independence. We had a mind of our own. Our foreign policy was guided by what benefits India. By our size, our history and our relationships, we should be involved in these global conversations. But frankly, India has become a side player. We have stepped back from the stage. We have a voice and a view, but that view is missing. There was already pain in India. The Iran war magnified it, pushing people over the edge. We cannot sit in India and remain unconcerned about what is happening in the rest of the world. The post-World War II security structure was built by the West. The next global architecture will be built by multiple civilisations. A nation of 1.5 billion people must help shape it. We want stability. We want an order designed not just by speaking, but by listening equally.
— Rahul Gandhi (@RahulGandhi) November 19, 2026
Questioning the Modi government's emphasis on personal relationships between world leaders, Gandhi said international diplomacy must be guided by geopolitical and economic interests rather than individual friendships.
"Friendship is not the point. Who gives a damn about friendship? Do you really think that geopolitics is going to work because the guy is your friend? He's leading a structure. He's got a whole economic system under him. He's not going to make decisions based on whether he likes you or doesn't like you. So these are some of the things that disturb me," Gandhi said.
Clarifying his position, he said he had no objection to political leaders maintaining cordial personal relationships, but argued that such ties could not substitute for a clear understanding of international developments and India's strategic interests.
"I don't have a problem with being friends with Mr Modi or being friends with leaders. Friendship is not that important. What's important is that you understand what's going on, who you are, and where you fit," he said.
Gandhi also spoke about the emerging global power structure, arguing that international affairs would increasingly be shaped by several major countries and civilisations rather than dominated by a single geopolitical bloc.
"The next global architecture will not be built by one civilisation alone. It will be shaped by multiple civilisations, with America, China, India, the Middle East and Russia all having a role to play," he said.

Saurabh Mukherjee
Comments (0)
Leave a Comment