A speech by Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) national president Nitin Nabin in Punjab has triggered controversy after a video surfaced in which he appeared to invoke the state's soldiers while calling for the removal of the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) government.
The remarks, made during a party event in Jalandhar on November 18, have drawn attention to the restrictions on using the armed forces in political campaigns.
In a video circulating on social media on Thursday (November 19), Nabin refers to Punjab's history and its “nationally-respected soldiers” while urging people to bring down the Bhagwant Mann-led government.
“Agar aaj Punjab ke fouji sankalp kar lengey toh AAP ki sarkaar ko bhi ukhaad phekney mein safal hongey (If Punjab’s soldiers resolve to do so today, they will also succeed in uprooting the AAP government),” he says.
The remarks have raised questions over the invocation of military personnel in the context of electoral politics, particularly with Punjab scheduled to hold its next Assembly election in 2027.
The statement was reportedly made at the launch of the BJP's ‘Samrasta Sankalp Yatra’ in Jalandhar, a prominent cantonment city in central Punjab, on November 18, according to reports.
The 16-day nationwide tour, launched by Nabin in Jalandhar, is being organised by the BJP under the banner of the Samrasta Sankalp Yatra. The party's announcement described the programme as a 16-day initiative.
Another part of Nabin's speech has also come under scrutiny because of its proximity to the reference to soldiers.
Before making the remark, he said: “Mai aapko spashth roop se kehta hoon – Punjab ne jab-jab angdai li hai, unhoney parivartan laaya hai (I want to make myself clear. Whenever Punjab has awakened, it has brought change.”
The use of the word angdai, which can refer to political awakening and collective mobilisation, has acquired a particular significance when read alongside his appeal invoking Punjab's soldiers to bring down the elected government.
The Election Commission of India (ECI) has previously cautioned political parties against bringing the armed forces into election campaigning. In 2013, the commission issued guidelines stating that the armed forces, including the police, are “apolitical and neutral stakeholders” in Indian democracy.
Political parties were asked to “exercise great caution while making any reference to the armed forces in their political campaigns [speeches]”. The guidelines also restrict the use of armed personnel in visual election campaigns.
The Representation of the People Act, 1951, also places legal restrictions on seeking electoral assistance from serving personnel.
Section 123(7) of the Act identifies obtaining or procuring assistance from members of the armed forces and certain public officials to advance a candidate's electoral prospects as a corrupt electoral practice. The provision was also central to the landmark Indira Gandhi v. Raj Narain election case of 1975.
The controversy over Nabin's remarks also brings back memories of the BJP's use of military-related events during the 2019 Lok Sabha election campaign. Prime Minister Narendra Modi had referred to the Pulwama attack and the Balakot airstrike while addressing election rallies.
The ECI had then said that Modi did not “directly ask” for votes. Subsequently, political parties were instructed against using photographs of defence personnel in election advertisements or designing campaign material around the armed forces.
Nabin has repeatedly targeted the AAP government in Punjab, describing the Bhagwant Mann-led administration as a “curse for Punjab” and urging voters to remove it in the 2027 Assembly elections. In his November 18 address, he also spoke about the state's farmers, alleging that they were suffering under BJP rule.
The reference to farmers is significant given Punjab's central role in the nationwide farmers' movement against the BJP-led Union government's three controversial farm laws. The agitation, regarded as one of the longest mass protests in recent history, eventually forced the government to repeal the laws.
The movement also led to the breakdown of the Shiromani Akali Dal-BJP alliance, although the two parties have since moved closer again amid preparations for the forthcoming Assembly election.
The remarks, made during a party event in Jalandhar on November 18, have drawn attention to the restrictions on using the armed forces in political campaigns.
In a video circulating on social media on Thursday (November 19), Nabin refers to Punjab's history and its “nationally-respected soldiers” while urging people to bring down the Bhagwant Mann-led government.
“Agar aaj Punjab ke fouji sankalp kar lengey toh AAP ki sarkaar ko bhi ukhaad phekney mein safal hongey (If Punjab’s soldiers resolve to do so today, they will also succeed in uprooting the AAP government),” he says.
The remarks have raised questions over the invocation of military personnel in the context of electoral politics, particularly with Punjab scheduled to hold its next Assembly election in 2027.
The statement was reportedly made at the launch of the BJP's ‘Samrasta Sankalp Yatra’ in Jalandhar, a prominent cantonment city in central Punjab, on November 18, according to reports.
The 16-day nationwide tour, launched by Nabin in Jalandhar, is being organised by the BJP under the banner of the Samrasta Sankalp Yatra. The party's announcement described the programme as a 16-day initiative.
Another part of Nabin's speech has also come under scrutiny because of its proximity to the reference to soldiers.
Before making the remark, he said: “Mai aapko spashth roop se kehta hoon – Punjab ne jab-jab angdai li hai, unhoney parivartan laaya hai (I want to make myself clear. Whenever Punjab has awakened, it has brought change.”
The use of the word angdai, which can refer to political awakening and collective mobilisation, has acquired a particular significance when read alongside his appeal invoking Punjab's soldiers to bring down the elected government.
The Election Commission of India (ECI) has previously cautioned political parties against bringing the armed forces into election campaigning. In 2013, the commission issued guidelines stating that the armed forces, including the police, are “apolitical and neutral stakeholders” in Indian democracy.
Political parties were asked to “exercise great caution while making any reference to the armed forces in their political campaigns [speeches]”. The guidelines also restrict the use of armed personnel in visual election campaigns.
The Representation of the People Act, 1951, also places legal restrictions on seeking electoral assistance from serving personnel.
Section 123(7) of the Act identifies obtaining or procuring assistance from members of the armed forces and certain public officials to advance a candidate's electoral prospects as a corrupt electoral practice. The provision was also central to the landmark Indira Gandhi v. Raj Narain election case of 1975.
The controversy over Nabin's remarks also brings back memories of the BJP's use of military-related events during the 2019 Lok Sabha election campaign. Prime Minister Narendra Modi had referred to the Pulwama attack and the Balakot airstrike while addressing election rallies.
The ECI had then said that Modi did not “directly ask” for votes. Subsequently, political parties were instructed against using photographs of defence personnel in election advertisements or designing campaign material around the armed forces.
Nabin has repeatedly targeted the AAP government in Punjab, describing the Bhagwant Mann-led administration as a “curse for Punjab” and urging voters to remove it in the 2027 Assembly elections. In his November 18 address, he also spoke about the state's farmers, alleging that they were suffering under BJP rule.
The reference to farmers is significant given Punjab's central role in the nationwide farmers' movement against the BJP-led Union government's three controversial farm laws. The agitation, regarded as one of the longest mass protests in recent history, eventually forced the government to repeal the laws.
The movement also led to the breakdown of the Shiromani Akali Dal-BJP alliance, although the two parties have since moved closer again amid preparations for the forthcoming Assembly election.

The Crossbill News Desk
Comments (0)
Leave a Comment