The Supreme Court has directed the Union government not to relocate books from the 135-year-old Central Secretariat Library (CSL) until the next hearing, expressing displeasure over the manner in which the collection was being handled and questioning the urgency behind the shifting exercise.
A bench of Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva passed the direction on Monday (November 16) after amicus curiae and senior advocate Haripriya Padmanabhan raised concerns about the condition of the books and the proposed relocation process, Live Law reported.
Padmanabhan informed the court that the authorities appeared to be rushing to complete the shifting exercise by November and urged the bench to halt the process. She also drew attention to books stored at a facility in Delhi's R.K. Puram, which she had personally visited, describing their condition as “atrocious”.
Additional Solicitor General (ASG) Aishwarya Bhati subsequently told the court that the books at the location had come from the Tulsi Sadan Library. The bench asked Padmanabhan to verify whether the books carried the library's identification tags.
Expressing strong displeasure over the handling of the collection, Justice Kumar questioned the government's approach and emphasised the historical importance of the books.
“You are just in a hurry to get done with this. What are you planning to do with these books? There seems to be an ad hoc approach. You are not bothered about…, this is some heritage. Basically, a heritage for us dating back to 1702. If you don’t want them, give it to some other country that will value them…Show some respect to these books; two lakh books thrown to the wind,” Justice Kumar told Bhati, questioning why the authorities were in such a hurry to relocate them.
The amicus curiae also sought greater transparency from the Union government regarding the facilities available at the proposed new location. She called for a comparison of the space currently occupied by bookshelves and the area earmarked for them at the new premises.
“I would like them to give a breakup of how much is presently being used for bookshelves and compare it with how much is used in the new place,” she said.
Taking note of the concerns, the bench directed the government to suspend the relocation of the books until the next hearing.
“You will not shift the books then,” Justice Kumar told the government.
The court recorded the government's assurance that no books would be moved before the next hearing and scheduled the matter for November 20.
“ASG says the books will not be shifted until next hearing. List on 20th November. In the meanwhile, the affidavit came to be filed today shall be placed on record,” the court said in its order, according to Live Law.
The Union government informed the bench that it had filed an affidavit on Monday and sought an early hearing of the matter.
A bench of Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva passed the direction on Monday (November 16) after amicus curiae and senior advocate Haripriya Padmanabhan raised concerns about the condition of the books and the proposed relocation process, Live Law reported.
Padmanabhan informed the court that the authorities appeared to be rushing to complete the shifting exercise by November and urged the bench to halt the process. She also drew attention to books stored at a facility in Delhi's R.K. Puram, which she had personally visited, describing their condition as “atrocious”.
Additional Solicitor General (ASG) Aishwarya Bhati subsequently told the court that the books at the location had come from the Tulsi Sadan Library. The bench asked Padmanabhan to verify whether the books carried the library's identification tags.
Expressing strong displeasure over the handling of the collection, Justice Kumar questioned the government's approach and emphasised the historical importance of the books.
“You are just in a hurry to get done with this. What are you planning to do with these books? There seems to be an ad hoc approach. You are not bothered about…, this is some heritage. Basically, a heritage for us dating back to 1702. If you don’t want them, give it to some other country that will value them…Show some respect to these books; two lakh books thrown to the wind,” Justice Kumar told Bhati, questioning why the authorities were in such a hurry to relocate them.
The amicus curiae also sought greater transparency from the Union government regarding the facilities available at the proposed new location. She called for a comparison of the space currently occupied by bookshelves and the area earmarked for them at the new premises.
“I would like them to give a breakup of how much is presently being used for bookshelves and compare it with how much is used in the new place,” she said.
Taking note of the concerns, the bench directed the government to suspend the relocation of the books until the next hearing.
“You will not shift the books then,” Justice Kumar told the government.
The court recorded the government's assurance that no books would be moved before the next hearing and scheduled the matter for November 20.
“ASG says the books will not be shifted until next hearing. List on 20th November. In the meanwhile, the affidavit came to be filed today shall be placed on record,” the court said in its order, according to Live Law.
The Union government informed the bench that it had filed an affidavit on Monday and sought an early hearing of the matter.

The Crossbill News Desk
Comments (0)
Leave a Comment