Law

Supreme Court Directs ECI To Probe Alleged Fake Form 7 Applications In Delhi’s Mustafabad

The court directed the authorities to verify the complaints and initiate appropriate corrective action if the allegations were established.

Supreme Court Directs ECI To Probe Alleged Fake Form 7 Applications In Delhi’s Mustafabad

Meeting of Mustafabad ERO with BLO Supervisors earlier this month. Photo: X/@dm_northeast

The Supreme Court on Thursday (November 19) asked the Election Commission of India (ECI) and the Chief Electoral Officer (CEO) of Delhi to investigate allegations of fraudulent Form 7 applications seeking the deletion of genuine voters from the electoral rolls in the Mustafabad constituency during the ongoing Special Intensive Revision (SIR) exercise.

The court directed the authorities to verify the complaints and initiate appropriate corrective action if the allegations were established. The bench, however, disposed of a writ petition filed by Congress leader Ali Mehdi without making any observations on its merits, Live Law reported.

The matter was heard by a bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana.

Mehdi's petition drew upon media reports, including an investigation published by The Hindu, which highlighted instances of alleged manipulation in the voter deletion process.

Several Booth Level Agents (BLAs) whose names appeared on Form 7 applications reportedly denied signing or submitting the objections. The applications had sought the removal of voters by claiming that they were either dead or had shifted from their registered addresses, although some of those individuals were found to be alive and residing at the same addresses.

The Mustafabad allegations add to a growing number of complaints surrounding the use of Form 7 during the SIR exercise across the country.

Reports of bulk objections and alleged attempts to remove eligible voters from electoral rolls have emerged from several states, including Karnataka, Uttarakhand, Telangana, West Bengal and Gujarat. In several of these cases, allegations have specifically been raised that BJP leaders or party workers were involved in filing objections in bulk to facilitate the deletion of voters' names.

The Congress leader argued that the applications were not submitted by genuine objectors and were instead being used to target legitimate voters. He cited a report documenting 28 such electors who continued to reside at their registered addresses despite deletion requests being filed against their names.

During the proceedings, the petitioner's counsel informed the court that 36 out of 37 Form 7 applications examined had been found to be false.

The bench, however, pointed out that the ECI had limited authority over BLAs, who are appointed by political parties. Justice Bagchi observed that the commission could take action against agents found to have submitted fraudulent applications.

“If a booth-level agent makes a fraudulent application, the Election Commission can blacklist him. Beyond that, they have no control,” Justice Bagchi observed, reported Live Law.

The allegations come amid questions over the transparency of the Form 7 disclosure process in Delhi.

According to The Hindu, the Delhi CEO received 13,462 applications seeking voter deletions between August 31 and October 16, but only 9,199 were made public. As many as 4,263 applications, accounting for 31.67% of the total, were missing from the mandatory public disclosures.

The ECI's Manual on Electoral Roll 2023 requires objections submitted through Form 7 to be published in Form 10 lists for seven days before any decision is taken. These lists must also be circulated among political parties and displayed on notice boards. Except in cases involving the death of a voter, the concerned elector must receive an individual notice and be allowed 15 days to respond to the objection.

Mehdi also brought to the court's attention an earlier intervention by the Supreme Court during the Uttar Pradesh SIR proceedings, when the ECI was directed to take corrective steps in response to the bulk submission of Form 7 applications.

The petitioner further told the bench that the police had declined to register an FIR on the basis of his complaint. Justice Bagchi suggested that he could approach a magistrate for relief. Taking note of the fact that Mehdi had already approached various authorities with his complaints, the court decided to dispose of the petition while directing the concerned officials to examine the allegations.

“Since the petitioner has already submitted a representation, we dispose of the writ petition, without expressing any opinion, with a direction to the authorities to verify the allegation and take necessary remedial measures strictly in accordance with law,” the bench said.

Comments (0)

Leave a Comment

   Can't Read ? Click    Refresh