Law

Journalists’ Body Rebuts Delhi Police Affidavit, Flags Rights Violations During Protests Before SC

The journalists’ organisation argued that police cannot escape accountability for restraining journalists simply by avoiding terms such as arrest or detention.

Journalists’ Body Rebuts Delhi Police Affidavit, Flags Rights Violations During Protests Before SC

Delhi Police beat protesters, including student leader Aishe Ghosh, on October 10. Photo: Left Views.

The Network of Women in Media, India (NWMI) has challenged the Delhi Police’s claim that its actions against journalists during the anti-Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) protests in the capital amounted merely to crowd management, telling the Supreme Court that such explanations cannot override constitutional protections of personal liberty and press freedom.

In a rejoinder affidavit filed on November 21, the journalists’ organisation argued that police cannot escape accountability for restraining journalists simply by avoiding terms such as arrest or detention. It also maintained that the right to gather and report news cannot be restricted on the grounds that a person lacks official accreditation, formal employment with a recognised media organisation or an identity card issued by an employer.

The affidavit was submitted in response to the Delhi Police’s counter affidavit in a petition concerning allegations that journalists were removed and harassed while covering protests against Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) Gyanesh Kumar last month.

“The police cannot justify an interference with personal liberty simply by refraining from calling it a detention or arrest,” the NWMI affidavit was quoted as saying by Live Law.

The organisation pointed out that the police had contradicted their own denial of interference with journalists by admitting in their affidavit that some journalists were removed from protest sites, placed in police vehicles for verification and subsequently released.

According to the NWMI, these admissions themselves establish interference with their personal liberty and professional work.

It further argued that describing such actions as “removal for verification”, “crowd control”, “mistaken identity” or “bona fide error” does not change their nature or absolve the police of responsibility.

The dispute stems from police abuse, assault, detention and arrests during protests against the Election Commission's handling of the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls.

The demonstrations, which began on September 25, were held around Jantar Mantar and other parts of central Delhi in October. Journalists, lawyers, students and other protesters were among those allegedly targeted, irrespective of their professional identities.

A key issue raised by the NWMI is the Delhi Police's attempt to distinguish accredited journalists working for recognised media organisations from social media content creators. The police had argued that protections extended to journalists covering protests should not automatically apply to social media influencers.

Rejecting this distinction, the NWMI maintained that the nature of the activity, rather than the professional status or institutional affiliation of the individual, should determine whether constitutional protection applies.

“What matters is what the person was doing: recording police action at a public protest for publication is newsgathering and dissemination, irrespective of the duration, format or platform employed,” it stated in its affidavit.

The Delhi Police, in its response, had denied violating journalists' rights to cover the protests or obstructing the dissemination of news. However, it acknowledged that some journalists were “inadvertently” removed, attributing the incidents to “misidentification”.

The police also cited central media accreditation guidelines, which require journalism to be a person's “principal vocation” and their employment in or association with a “recognised” news establishment. It further invoked the Press Council of India's controversial October 15 guidelines seeking to define who qualifies as a journalist.

The NWMI has countered that even the Delhi Police acknowledged that journalists cannot be denied their right to gather news merely because they do not possess Press Information Bureau (PIB)-issued identity cards. It argued that Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution guarantees freedom of speech and expression regardless of the medium through which information is gathered or disseminated.

The organisation also highlighted what it described as contradictions in the police's position. While the Delhi Police claimed that no restrictions had been imposed on citizens' rights to report or disseminate information, it also maintained that the restrictions imposed on the day of the protests were “uniformly” applicable to everyone, including journalists.

The rejoinder brings the question of police accountability and the scope of press freedom at public demonstrations into sharper focus, challenging any attempt to make the right to gather and disseminate news dependent on official recognition or institutional credentials.

Comments (0)

Leave a Comment

   Can't Read ? Click    Refresh