Law

ECI Opposes Rahul Gandhi’s 48 Questions on SIR, Supreme Court Hearing on December 9

The bench adjourned the matter until December 9, allowing the ECI to file its objections to the application.

ECI Opposes Rahul Gandhi’s 48 Questions on SIR, Supreme Court Hearing on December 9

Congress leader Rahul Gandhi, with the Supreme Court of India in the background. Photo: File and Facebook

The Election Commission of India (ECI) has opposed a plea by Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi and other INDIA bloc leaders seeking answers to 48 questions from Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) Gyanesh Kumar and Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi regarding the conduct of the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls.

The matter came up before a Supreme Court bench headed by Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant on Tuesday (November 17). Senior advocate Kapil Sibal, appearing for Gandhi, informed the court that the petitioners had filed an application on Monday questioning the ECI's claims in its counter affidavit submitted on October 26. He argued that the poll body had relied on assertions that decisions concerning the SIR were unanimous but had provided no material evidence to substantiate them, Live Law reported.

Sibal submitted that the petitioners had sought interrogatories from the Election Commission and requested the court to issue notice on their application.

However, senior advocate Harish Salve, appearing for the ECI, told the bench that the Commission had serious reservations about the application. Salve, along with senior advocate Maninder Singh, opposed the issuance of notice before a preliminary hearing on the matter, The Hindu reported.

“We will then hear the application and pass necessary orders,” CJI Surya Kant was quoted as saying by the newspaper.

The bench adjourned the matter until December 9, allowing the ECI to file its objections to the application.

In their rejoinder submitted on Monday, the INDIA bloc leaders challenged the Commission's October counter affidavit, arguing that it contained no “minutes of the meeting, file notings, recorded approvals” to establish that the decision to undertake the SIR had been taken unanimously.

They also questioned the affidavit's authorisation, pointing out that it had been filed by Deputy Election Commissioner Bhanu Prakash Yeturu with the purported approval of the CEC and the two Election Commissioners, but contained no details or dates indicating when such approval had been granted.

The application includes 48 interrogatories addressed to CEC Kumar, ECs Sandhu and Joshi, and senior officials involved in the revision exercise. The questions seek documentary and electronic records, including file numbers, official communications, WhatsApp exchanges and details of occasions when the two Election Commissioners recorded objections to decisions relating to the SIR.

Among other things, the INDIA bloc leaders have asked the ECI to disclose how decisions concerning the revision were taken, whether through formal meetings, circulation of files or electronic communication. They have also sought the dates on which each member of the Commission approved the decisions.

The application further highlights an alleged contradiction between the ECI's claim that the SIR decision was unanimous and an earlier response to a Right to Information (RTI) query. In that response, the Commission had stated that “the Commission has so far not taken any decision on initiating an SIR across the country in 2025”.

Questions Over Dissent Within Election Commission

The INDIA bloc leaders have separately sought details of objections and dissent recorded by Election Commissioners Sandhu and Joshi regarding the SIR, including matters concerning changes to Form 6 and the functioning of the ECINET platform. They have asked the Commission to specify the number of such instances between February 2025 and October 2026.

The interrogatories also seek information about objections filed through Form 7, including the number submitted by individuals and Booth Level Agents, cases involving false or non-existent persons, and the action taken in response. The petitioners have additionally asked whether any electoral roll entry was ever modified, added or deleted without an order from an Electoral Registration Officer (ERO).

Another set of questions concerns Joshi's proposal for an audit of individuals who have access to and the ability to modify the electoral roll database. The leaders have sought details of whether the proposal was placed before the Commission, along with relevant dates and file records.

They have also asked for the total number of appeals filed by the ECI or its officials before judicial tribunals in West Bengal against orders passed by judicial officers directing the inclusion of names in electoral rolls. The application further seeks clarification on whether the ECINET platform provided EROs with the facility to restore deleted voter entries and whether the facility was unavailable at any point.

In September, The Indian Express first reported that two of the three Election Commissioners had raised objections on 14 occasions over a period of 10 months concerning the conduct of the SIR.

The latest legal challenge seeks to establish the documentary basis of the Commission's decisions and bring greater clarity to the role of its individual members in the exercise. With the ECI now set to file its objections, the Supreme Court is scheduled to take up the matter again on December 9.

Comments (0)

Leave a Comment

   Can't Read ? Click    Refresh